MONDAY, MARCH 24 ● Kissimmee, vs Florida
This is the day we discuss the last cuts. This is a big one, I suppose. I have a theory, however, that it is not as big as we make it out to be. By “we,” I mean the power structure within the ballclub, the players on the team, and the media.
Everyone treats this cut as if it is life-and-death. If you had to stick with your picks all year long, it would be a fateful day. But my experience tells me that the team will change as often as a chameleon as the season moves on.
It takes 35 or 40 men to win a championship, but we must cut down to 25 for Opening Day. In a typical year, we will lose five players to injuries, and move ten or so up and down, depending on performance and need.
For example, we will keep veteran infielder Luis Rivera to play a backup role. But if one of our front-line infielders gets hurt, we will likely call up Russ Johnson or Luis Lopez to start. Because Johnson and Lopez are relatively young, it is thought that they will perform better on an everyday basis. Rivera has plenty of experience, and he understands the role of a backup player. Though he has a little less speed and power than the others, it is thought that he will perform better part-time than the other two.
Our toughest cut will be Donne Wall. Donne is the Rodney Dangerfield of pitchers. He doesn’t throw hard; doesn’t have a good breaking pitch. His strengths are good control of the fastball and a terrific changeup.
If he were lefthanded, he could get some respect with this repertoire. But he is righthanded. As a result, he has spent two years at A ball, two more at AA, and two at AAA. Each year he has posted a winning record. Each year, the brain trust has said, “Yeah, but if we move him up, he’ll be overmatched. You can’t pitch at that level with his stuff.”
Last year, we got desperate and called Donne to the major leagues. It was the first time he had ever been on the roster. All those years, all those wins, and never on the roster. Most teams have guys on the big-league roster who have never had a winning year. We have exposed Donne to the winter draft year after year, and no team has drafted him.
So what did he do when we called him up? He went 9-8 with a respectable ERA, and he pitched 150 innings. Don’t ask me how he did it; I don’t like his stuff, either. But I have tremendous respect for his ability to win. Believe me, it is not easy to win, year after year.
Sometimes you get in a rut with your control and go on a losing streak. Sometimes you get into a spot in the rotation where the team doesn’t score any runs when you are pitching. Nolan Ryan won the ERA title one season, and finished 8-16. Donne Wall has a seven-year winning streak.
Unfortunately, Donne’s control has been off this spring. He just can’t seem get his fastball on the corners. With control, his slow fastball is good. Without control, it is terrible. His changeup depends on his fastball. Without control, he is dead meat. And that has been the story for him this spring.
Today I presented Gerry with the coaches’ ballots. The only two that included Donne Wall were mine and The Perfessor’s. Interesting, isn’t it? Not one nonpitcher wants him on the team; both ex-pitchers still think he can win.
“What it really comes down to,” Gerry said, “is Donne Wall or Chris Holt. Which one do you want in the rotation?”
This choice was given to us because we don’t want to lose Jóse Lima, Ramón Garcia, or Russ Springer. Each of these guys throws harder than Donne, and each probably has more trade value. But they have not been winners; Donne has won at each level.
None of us want to see Holt go to the minors; he is ready for prime-time now. And if he doesn’t get his brain bent by major-league adversity, he will probably win more games than Wall could.
My question was: “What about Kile?”
We had just watched Darryl “The Enigma” stink it up again — this time against the Marlins. He has not pitched as poorly as Wall this spring, but he hasn’t pitched well at all.
What makes it worse is that he shows no desire whatsoever to accept coaching. Every time you try to coax him into a conversation about pitching mechanics or strategy, he starts spouting his own convoluted theories as if they were gospel.
That’s my take on Kile: call it off. I can’t work the puzzle.

Socrates would have a field day with this guy. If you asked D.K. enough questions, he would meet himself coming and going. You say eether and I say eyether; you day neether and I say nyether; you say vanilla and I say vanillo, you say tomayto and I say tomahto. Let’s call the whole thing off.
That’s my take on Kile: call it off. I can’t work the puzzle.
“I’ll tell you what,” I said. “What we are doing here is forecasting the future. We know what these guys have done in the past. And we know what we have seen with our own eyes down here. But we don’t know what these guys are going to do this year.
“My opinion is that if you start all these guys all year long, the win totals of the pitchers will go in this order: Reynolds, Hampton, Holt, Wall, Kile, Fernandez. So I don’t see this as Holt or Wall. I see it as pray for Sid and trade Kile.”
I got a few grins out of that summary, but I was serious. Gerry was a little impatient. He sometimes gets that way with me and my counterculture thinking.
“Let’s be realistic,” he said. “Kile has to be in the rotation unless I trade him this week. And there is a market for him. But if we demote him, there will be no market. Sid is Sid. He’s won over 100 games, and he’s still hard to hit when you can roll him out there. Wall and Holt still have options. If we need them, all we have to do is call them up.”
As usual, it was hard to refute his logic. But I sure am tired of watching Kile. When I was broadcasting, I used to take my headset off between innings and tell my TV partner, Bill Brown, “You couldn’t pay me to watch this guy pitch. Well, you could, I guess, because that’s what I’m doing. But I sure wouldn’t classify this as entertainment. It’s more like torture.”
Lest I sound too abrasive, I must admit that this guy has pitched a no-hitter, made the All-Star team, and won 15 games in a single season. He has never had an arm problem, and he can throw more pitches in a game without losing velocity than any pitcher in our entire organization. He does have exceptional talent. I guess that’s why it is so hard to watch him struggle.
You want to help, but he won’t let you.
The other problem we have is with Pat Listach, our Opening Day shortstop. When Cubby rated
our shortstops, he said, “Rivera is the best. He’s a decent backup. Lopez misses a lot of ground balls in practice. He’s not really a shortstop; he’s a second-baseman. By far the worst, when it comes to catching the ball and accurate throwing, is Listach. I’d like to say he’s improving, but I can’t see it.”
I think everyone would endorse a Kile-for-a-front-line-shortstop deal right now. But it seems unlikely that that kind of deal can be done. So we go into the season with a reluctant centerfielder, no real shortstop, and three pitchers who have never been successful anywhere. Not to worry.
“I’ve always said that the team that wins the championship is not the team that has the best lineup on Opening Day, but the team that improves the most over the year,” I said. “With this setup, we have a lot of room for improvement.”
Of course, I said this partially in jest. Every team in our division has similar problems. We still have Biggio, Bagwell, Bell, Gonzalez, Berry, five or six good pitchers, and five or six good complementary players. Things could be worse. My buddies from Astros days of yore, A’s manager Art Howe and Brewers manager Phil Garner, are in worse shape than I am.
We lost 7-6 to the Marlins today. Thomas Howard got a couple of hits, but he missed another fly
ball in right field. He has missed them in left, right, and center now. When they told us he could play all three positions equally well, they were right.
This makes it easy to give the nod to Abreu at the start. Somehow I have the feeling that Howard is better in the field than what we have seen so far. I still wouldn’t be surprised if he ends up starting a lot of games this year. Time will tell.
If my crystal ball is working, it could prove to be my best asset in the long run.